The Devil in the White City
I finished reading Erik Larson's The Devil in the White City a couple of weeks ago. It was a very good read. I am not usually a nonfiction reader, when reading for leisure, but I really enjoyed this one a great deal.
The book got me to thinking about a number of different things, and I wrote a review of it for the really cool new online lit mag Sloth Jockey. There were a lot of things I could have included in the review, but didn't want it to get too long for people to read (or for the editor to include).
One of the things that I had to leave out was the fascinating idea of H. H. Holmes, the serial killer whose story is one of the two main threads in the book, as a harvester of body parts. Sometimes, I think we like to think of questions of harvesting organs and/or DNA as a new ethical dilemma brought about by the great strides we've made in medical technology in recent years. That's true, to an extent. But I think it is easy to overlook that the progress has been strides, and not leaps. There is a flow to the technology that has developed, and the ethical questions that are raised by the advances in technology don't sit in a vacuum. Rather, these advances have taken place slowly over time, and the ethical questions have been there throughout that time.
When H. H. Holmes and that other famous murderer across the Pond were doing their gruesome dissections, it was only a relatively short time after the writing of Frankenstein, another book which considers ethical questions which might seem to be a bit ahead of their time. For me, one of the beauties of Larson's narrative is that it gives some perspective about where we sit in the whole scheme of this flow of progress โ and that this place is not really so unique (and exciting) as we might like to think.
And of course, the presentation of the attitudes toward progress that were largely held in Chicago โ and the whole nation โ at the time is pretty depressing. Hubris sticks so close to humans that you might think of it as a faithful companion. Too bad it's the sort of companion that might be said to corrupt good morals.




